401(k) vs. Roth
Oct 24th, 2007 by Nut
It really shouldn’t be one vs. the other, which is what this Q & A addresses.
I have both and I just love the flexibility of the Roth. I run it through Scottrade and I’m very happy with my options there. Eventually I want to move it to Vanguard, but I need to have more money in the account to be exempt of paying certain fees. I’m also a big believer in index funds (which is Vanguard’s specialty) but I do own one stock (Berkshire Hathaway) and Scottrade allows me to own both in one account with no problem.
If I switched to Vanguard I would have to have a special account that allows for both the index funds and stocks, and since that costs extra I’m waiting on it.
But right now I’m paying .5% in expense ratios for my index funds, and that’s high compared to the .2% (ish) that vanguard charges for the very same product.
As for the 401(k) account, the cheapest index fund (a standard S&P 500 index) costs .7%. And that’s the cheapest one!
I’ve crunched the numbers and right now it pays off for me to stay with Scottrade and pay the slightly higher expense ratios instead of the flat, monthly fee that Vanguard charges.
If you want to know why ETFs in your retirement account are a scam, click here.
Open an ING account and get a $25 bonus!
Broken English
I have a Roth IRA through Scottrade!!
This is getting a little too weird GG
[...] 8th, 2007 by Nut The other day I noticed one particular post I wrote was getting a crazy amount of hits and after looking at the numbers I realized it was [...]
[...] was checking my stats today and noticed my Roth IRA vs 401(k) post was getting a lot of hits. Then I noticed that most of them were coming from the wsj.com [...]
[...] other day I noticed one particular post I wrote was getting a crazy amount of hits and after looking at the numbers I realized it was [...]
[...] I’m finally transferring my Roth IRA from Scottrade to Vanguard after finding out that you can have two Roths [...]